legal malpractice lawyer call 410-486-1800 24/7
Jack I Hyatt Attorney at Law
You can call at any time to ask about the progress of your case.
Home

Legal Malpractice Defined

Standard of Proof

Case Within a Case

Changes in the Law

Attorney Judgment Rule

Defenses to Malpractice

Retaining A Malpractice Lawyer

Links

Link Exchange


Click to e-mail any question

The Case Within A Case

In many legal malpractice actions, there may be discussion of whether the plaintiff could win the "case within a case". This discussion occurs in malpractice cases involving prior litigation, where a plaintiff claims to have either lost or to have recovered a smaller amount of damages than warranted by the facts and law, as a result of the original lawyer's malpractice.

In order for the plaintiff to establish that damages were suffered as a result of the alleged malpractice, depending upon state law, it is often necessary for the plaintiff to prove that, but for the malpractice, a favorable verdict would have been won or greater damages recovered. In essence, this is a retrial of the original litigation within the context of the malpractice action - a case within a case.

Attorney-Client Privilege

It is important to note that within the context of a legal malpractice action, a lawyer may utilize what were formerly privileged communications from the client in order to respond to allegations of negligence.